Thursday, June 30, 2005

WORSE THAN ALL YOUR DREAMS

If you just can't get enough of my blather about The White Stripes, Flagpole has published my review of Get Behind Me Satan.
|
EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 8

Everything Idol is the year-long (so far) competition to determine, once and for all, The Best Thing Ever. After two rounds, the field has been whittled down to 24 contenders; in Round 3, we will reduce that number to 8, over eight semiweekly heats. Anyone and everyone may vote. Friends beat out Books and Sex in Heat 6, thereby ending my hopes for a Love vs. Sex final round. The six Quarterfinalists so far are:

Science
Love
Water
Email
Kitties
Friends

Polls remain open for one week for each heat; you can still vote in Heat 7, which has so far seen a neck-and-neck battle between Automobiles and Infinite Jest.

In Round 3, I will not be making new arguments for or against each contestant; instead, I will link to their appearances in the previous two rounds. Things will get a little more fun in the Quarterfinals.

The three things facing off in Heat 8, the final heat of Round 3, are:



1. His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman
Round 1
Round 2



2. Art
Round 1 (automatic bye)
Round 2



3. The Office
Round 1
Round 2

Polls close Wednesday, July 6 at midnight.
|

Wednesday, June 29, 2005

|

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 7

Everything Idol is the year-long (so far) competition to determine, once and for all, The Best Thing Ever. After two rounds, the field has been whittled down to 24 contenders; in Round 3, we will reduce that number to 8, over eight semiweekly heats. Anyone and everyone may vote. Kitties apparently just will not go away, as a last-minute voting surge pushed them over The Big Lebowski in Heat 5. The five Quarterfinalists so far are:

Science
Love
Water
Email
Kitties

Polls remain open for one week for each heat; you can still vote in Heat 6, which currently sees Friends beating Books and Sex.

In Round 3, I will not be making new arguments for or against each contestant; instead, I will link to their appearances in the previous two rounds. Things will get a little more fun in the Quarterfinals.

The three things facing off in Heat 7 are:



1. Johnny Cash, 1994-2003
Round 1
Round 2



2. Automobiles
Round 1
Round 2



3. Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace
Round 1
Round 2

Polls close Monday, July 4 at midnight.
|

Sunday, June 26, 2005

SO THIS IS WHAT THE VOLUME KNOB'S FOR

The Mountain Goats, the Troubadour, Los Angeles, June 25, 2005

I was unfamiliar with the music of John Darnielle (who is The Mountain Goats in the same way that Trent Reznor is Nine Inch Nails) until last year, and I've come to realize that there's a lot of catching up to do--he's apparently released albums at a rate of one per year since he started recording in 1991. He started out recording solo straight to a boombox, and the tape hiss and clicking (as heard on All Hail West Texas, for example) became an integral part of The Mountain Goats' sound, but on last year's We Shall All Be Healed and the new The Sunset Tree, he's traded in the hiss for a full band and production by John Vanderslice. He's also traded his fictional tales of teenage death-metal bands and halfway houses for true stories of his childhood (or as he put it at the show last night, "You're like yeah, a guy with an acoustic guitar singing about his childhood and adolescence. I'll buy that fucking record."), but his lyrics are still these airtight, crystalline short stories, shot through with perfect, indelible lines.

His show at the Troubadour took the form of a sort of career overview, starting with just a bassist and Darnielle himself on acoustic guitar. After a few songs, he informed the crowd that he'd be changing things up soon, so if anybody had any requests thatwas the time to make them. The room instantly became an unintelligible mass of screamed song titles; the guy behind me kept yelling "Death Metal!," but Darnielle unfortunately never played "The Best-Ever Death Metal Band in Denton."

After some fun stage patter that referenced both Leonard Cohen and Public Enemy, Vanderslice joined the band on electric guitar, and soon he was replaced by Franklin Bruno (who might be the least rock-n-roll-looking guy ever) on piano. Then a drummer replaced Bruno for the final two songs. The whole band came out for the encore, which culminated in a ferocious run-through of "Palmcorder Yajna" (available on mp3 at any of the Amazon links above). When that was over, the Troub turned on the music to signal the end of the show, but Darnielle, Bruno and the never-named bassist came back out for one more song, Tallahassee's "No Children," which Darnielle introduced as "a song to sing when you get your divorce." Something happened to his guitar after a verse or two, so he dropped it and took the microphone from its stand, leaning out over the edge of the stage and leading the crowd in a singalong of the song's climactic couplet: "I hope you die / I hope we both die."

Despite the "guy with an acoustic guitar singing about his childhood" element, Darnielle's live show has more in common with punk or metal than folky introspection. First of all, he looks kind of like Trent Reznor as a middle-management drone. Second of all, he's intense, to put it mildly, practically attacking his guitar and shouting wordlessly between verses. Live, everything is louder and faster than on record, accentuating the propulsive qualities of the music, and instead of burying his precise lyrics, it brings them into even sharper relief. It's got to be kind of weird to sing about your abusive stepfather to a couple hundred people who are all singing along, but it seemed to be working for everybody.

Golden Fiddle has "Dance Music" (the source of this post's title) at the top of its page, probably for a very limited time.

The Mountain Goats cover the Silver Jews' "Pet Politics" on the CD that comes with the new issue of The Believer. It's interesting to hear Darnielle, whose lyrics are usually straightforward in a Raymond Carver kind of way, tackle the wordplay of this song.

It's also interesting to me to realize that "Pet Politics" is originally a Silver Jews song, since I thought it was a Parker Paul original. Paul covered it on his debut album Lemon-Lime Room, and it fit in so well with the general bitter-fun-with-language vibe of the album that I just assumed he wrote it. Here's his version.
|

Friday, June 24, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | A Call to Arms

With just one week left to go in Round 3, it is time to look ahead to the Quarterfinals. What I'd like to do is to have a 3- or 4-person panel of judges, a la American Idol's Mean Guy, Fat Guy and Girl, to provide pithy comments on the contestants. All readers would still be able to vote, of course, but I thought it might be nice to get an "official" perspective besides mine for once. I figure anybody who's reading this blog on a weekend is just interested/obsessive enough to be into this, so if you want to be my Janice Dickinson, my Nigel Barker or (god forbid) my Nole, then shoot me an email (busoramaATgmailDOTcom) and let me know, before I start badgering you personally.

|

Thursday, June 23, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 6

Everything Idol is the year-long (so far) competition to determine, once and for all, The Best Thing Ever. After two rounds, the field has been whittled down to 24 contenders; in Round 3, we will reduce that number to 8, over eight semiweekly heats. Anyone and everyone may vote. Email beat out A/C and Rushmore to win Heat 4. The four Quarterfinalists so far are:

Science
Love
Water
Email

Polls remain open for one week for each heat; you can still vote in Heat 5, which currently sees a tie between kitties and The Big Lebowski.

In Round 3, I will not be making new arguments for or against each contestant; instead, I will link to their appearances in the previous two rounds. Things will get a little more fun in the Quarterfinals.

The three things facing off in Heat 6 are:



1. Friends
Round 1
Round 2



2. Sex
Round 1
Round 2



3. Books
Round 1
Round 2

Polls close Wednesday, June 29 at midnight.
|

Tuesday, June 21, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 5

Everything Idol is the year-long (so far) competition to determine, once and for all, The Best Thing Ever. After two rounds, the field has been whittled down to 24 contenders; in Round 3, we will reduce that number to 8, over eight semiweekly heats. Anyone and everyone may vote. Water barely edged out Swearing to win Heat 3. The three Quarterfinalists so far are:

Science
Love
Water

Polls remain open for one week for each heat; you can still vote in Heat 4, which so far sees Email beating Rushmore and Air Conditioning.

In Round 3, I will not be making new arguments for or against each contestant; instead, I will link to their appearances in the previous two rounds. Things will get a little more fun in the Quarterfinals.

The three things facing off in Heat 5 are:



1. The wheel
Round 1
Round 2



2. The Big Lebowski, directed by Joel Coen
Round 1
Round 2



3. Kitties
Round 1
Round 2

Polls close Monday, June 27 at midnight.
|

Monday, June 20, 2005

EFFLUVIA

1. Interesting opinion piece by Neal Stephenson (whose Snow Crash I'm nearly finished with) on Star Wars' effect on the culture.

2. Jimmy Carter Project Web Cam, where you can watch my brother build a house. He's the big guy in the sleeveless green t-shirt and green helmet.
|

Sunday, June 19, 2005

SWEAR TO ME!



BATMAN BEGINS - The first third, maybe half of this movie is almost certainly the best presentation of the origin of Batman in any medium. The juxtaposition of Bruce Wayne's martial-arts training with flashbacks to the life and death of his parents gives each phase of his development an emotional and thematic heft they've never had as separate entities, and it's that setup that sustains Batman Begins through its rather generic final act. Christian Bale is perfect as Bruce Wayne, nailing the guilt, the anger, the drive and the arrogance, while at the same time having a ball hamming it up as the Billionaire Playboy. He's less perfect as Batman, but I think that's due more to a poorly-designed costume and a half-hearted story philosophy. Director Christopher Nolan and writer David Goyer apparently decided that the Batman should be as frightening as possible, which was a great idea, but the execution leaves something to be desired, i.e. having Batman play the role of the monster in a horror movie is a good idea, but not if it just results in some extremely confusing fight scenes. And Bale's Batman voice skates the edge of the ludicrous; it sounds terrifying coming out of the shadows (or out of the black-skinned demon that one character sees under the influence of the Scarecrow's fear gas), less so when you can see the double chin that the costume gives Bale. The movie is full of great ideas poorly or haphazardly executed, and it's unfortunate that a relatively weak second half mars the greatness of the first.

Aside from Katie Holmes as Useless Generic Love Interest #798, the cast is uniformly excellent, particularly Michael Caine as Alfred and Liam Neeson as Wayne's mentor Ducard. Gary Oldman makes an impression as Sergeant Jim Gordon--he looks exactly like David Mazzuchelli's Year One Gordon--but he's relegated to being little more than Batman's sidekick, and spends most of the climax stuck in what's essentially a Batmobile video game. But his presence, as well as that of Bale, Caine and Morgan Freeman, gives me great hope for the inevitable sequel. Spider-Man 2 and X2 were both improvements over their predecessors, mainly because they can delve into the characters without spending half the movie just setting up and justifying the premise. Batman Begins, flawed though it is, has done a marvelous job of building a world; the real fun comes when the filmmakers are really allowed to play in it.

A FEW THOUGHTS ON A SEQUEL

It's pretty obvious that I'm not going to be writing the sequel, but if I was, here's a taste of what I would do (SPOILERS FOR BATMAN BEGINS!):

1. Lose Katie Holmes. She might already be under contract for a second film, but I'm sure she'll be too full of the Healing Love of Tom Cruise to care. Batman does not fall for dopey asssistant DAs; he likes girls who are into the same kinky shit as him. That means either Catwoman (and we don't need to go to that well again so soon) or...

2. Talia al Ghul. The daughter of Ras's al Ghul, the villain in Batman Begins. Talia arrives in Gotham, looking for revenge on the man who killed her father. (I'm seeing somebody like Asia Argento as Talia.) If Mrs. Cruise must be involved, then the first step in that revenge entails killing Assistant DA Rachel Dawes. With Dawes (and her boss, who was killed in Begins) out of the way, the way is cleared for...

3. Harvey Dent. An idealistic young DA about to have his spirit crushed by the corruption and perversity of Gotham. (I'm thinking Mark Ruffalo.) He will become a friend to Bruce Wayne and an ally to Batman and Gordon, fighting the crime bosses in the courts (when he can) and feeding info to Batman (when he can't). He's one of the few good men in Gotham, until the final act, when he's disfigured by...

4. The Joker. He's already set up by the end of Batman Begins, so it's a natural. He was an anonymous hood until Ra's al Ghul released the Scarecrow's fear gas on the Narrows; the gas warped his already criminal mind into something more terrifying than Gotham has ever seen. Adopting a ghoulish clown disguise (based on the visions he saw under the influence of the gas), he begins a spree of random robberies and senseless homicides that have everyone, even Batman and Gordon, scrambling to keep up. But after Gordon nearly captures him, the Joker makes things personal: he goes after Gordon's family. (If I was casting a Dark Knight Returns movie, Willem Dafoe or David Bowie would be my Joker. But one of the Entertainment Weekly reviewers, I think, suggested Peter Sarsgaard for a younger Joker, and I think that's a fantastic idea.)

Gordon would of course have a much larger role in this, and there would be a Bruce/Talia/Batman love/hate thing going on, without it being too much like the Batman/Catwoman relationship from Batman Returns. I haven't worked it all out, because nobody's paying me too. But you can see how this would lead into a third film, with Dent becoming Two-Face and the Joker making a cameo as the Hannibal Lecter of Gotham. I think it would be best to make a sequel with a third film in mind, so that they form a trilogy. That way, the sequel can end on a darker Empire Strikes Back-style note. The core of the story has to be Bruce Wayne's continued development, and since the first film is all about him creating Batman to master his fear and try to bring justice to Gotham, the second film should see him sinking further and further into the Batman persona, until Bruce Wayne really is the mask. Then the third is about him finding a balance between his two sides, with Two-Face as a nice visual metaphor.

You know, something like that. Hollywood, give me money.
|

Thursday, June 16, 2005

DISCUSSION TOPIC

Best movies of the first half of the decade (i.e. 2000-2004, so don't come at me with your Kung Fu Hustle or Revenge of the Sith). Here's the preliminary list I came up with during brief moments of downtime today, as well as how many times I've seen each one (in parentheses):

2000
Almost Famous (2)
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2)
Gladiator (at least 2, maybe 3)
Traffic (1)
Requiem for a Dream (1)
Bring It On (at least 3, maybe more)
High Fidelity (at least 2)
O Brother, Where Art Thou? (1)
Wonder Boys(1)

2001
The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (at least 5, probably more)
Donnie Darko (theatrical cut 1, director's cut 1)
The Man Who Wasn’t There (1)
Monsters, Inc. (2)
The Royal Tenenbaums (3 or 4)
Sexy Beast (2)
The Pledge (1)
Mulholland Dr. (2)
Memento (1)
Best in Show (1)
Ghost World (2)

2002
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (at least 5)
Adaptation (1)
Punch-Drunk Love (3)
Y Tu Mama Tambien (1)
Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones (4)
Secretary (2)
The Pianist (1)

2003
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (4)
Kill Bill Vol. 1 (1)
Finding Nemo (2)
X2 (2)
City of God (1)
Master and Commander (1)
Bad Santa (2)
Dogville (1)

2004
Kill Bill Vol. 2 (1)
Sideways (1)
The Incredibles (2)
Friday Night Lights (1)
Spider-Man 2 (1)
The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou (1)
Anchorman (3)
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (1)
Collateral (1)
Shaun of the Dead (1)


I know I'm forgetting a lot of stuff here. What were your favorites that aren't on the list so far (or why am I an idiot for including some of this stuff)?
|
EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 4

Everything Idol is the year-long (so far) competition to determine, once and for all, The Best Thing Ever. After two rounds, the field has been whittled down to 24 contenders; in Round 3, we will reduce that number to 8, over eight semiweekly heats. Anyone and everyone may vote. Love won Heat 2, to join Science as our second quarterfinalist. Polls remain open for one week for each heat; you can still vote in Heat 3, which so far sees Swearing edging out Water and Poetry.

In Round 3, I will not be making new arguments for or against each contestant; instead, I will link to their appearances in the previous two rounds. Things will get a little more fun in the Quarterfinals.

The three things facing off in Heat 4 are:



1. Email
Round 1
Round 2



2. Rushmore, directed by Wes Anderson
Round 1
Round 2



3. Air conditioning
Round 1
Round 2

Polls close Wednesday, June 22 at midnight.
|

Tuesday, June 14, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 3

Science wins Heat 1. You can still vote in Heat 2 through midnight tomorrow. Rules and explanations here.

The next three contestants, please:



1. Water
Round 1
Round 2



2. Poetry
Round 1 (automatic bye)
Round 2



3. Swearing
Round 1
Round 2

Anyone and everyone may vote. Polls close Monday, June 20 at midnight.
|

Thursday, June 09, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 2

See Tuesday's Heat 1 for an explanation of the rules, and to vote there if you haven't already. The next three contestants, please:



1. Music
Round 2 (automatic bye to Round 2)



2. The Daily Show with Jon Stewart

Round 1
Round 2



3. Love
Round 1
Round 2

Voting is open to everyone and anyone. Polls close Wednesday, June 15th at midnight.
|

Tuesday, June 07, 2005

EVERYTHING IDOL | Round 3, Heat 1

Hello, old friends and newcomers alike, and welcome to the third round of EVERYTHING IDOL, the year-long (so far) competition to determine The Best Thing Ever. Over the first two rounds, a huge list of nominees has been whittled down to 24 contestants. In Round 3, we're going to eliminate 16, leaving eight quarterfinalists.

We're going to do this round pretty quick and dirty, as I'd like to get to the more fun stuff I have planned for the Quarterfinals. Twice a week (on Tuesdays and Thursdays) for the next four weeks, I'll present you with three choices for Best Thing Ever. You vote. Anyone and everyone can vote, though you may vote only once, and God will know if you cheat, and then he will tell me, and we'll both be very upset.

I'm not going to write a lot of new stuff about each contestant this time, but I will link to their previous appearances in Rounds 1 and 2. Here's the complete list of Round 3 competitors:

Art
His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman
Water
Johnny Cash, 1994-2003
The Big Lebowski
Books
Air conditioning
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
Sex
Kitties
Automobiles
Coca-Cola
Swearing
Home cooking
Science
Email
Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace
Friends
Rushmore
Music
Love
The Office
Poetry
The wheel

Once again, the Angry Magic Duck will randomly draw names from the Straw Hat of Doom. (See here for an illustration of how this works.) I know some of you have problems with the Duck's methods, but be advised that he really doesn't care. And now, on with the show. The three contestants in Round 3, Heat 1 are:



1. Science
Round 2 (automatic bye to Round 2)



2. Home cooking
Round 1
Round 2



3. Coca-Cola
Round 1
Round 2

Polls close Monday, June 13 at midnight.
|

Monday, June 06, 2005

TWO CUTE ANIMALS, A GOOFY HAT, PIERCE BROSNAN AND THE WHITE STRIPES: A BRIEF TRIP TO GEORGIA

As you read this, I will have started work again after a month-and-a-half-long vacation/hiatus/unemployment period, which will somewhat ironically probably lead to an increase in blogging. But as I spent most of my break wearing out my TiVo, I decided to actually get out of my house for my final week of freedom. Therefore, I took a trip to the Boyhood Home in Georgia. This is what home looks like:



It's been a few years since I've seen it without a massive Dickens Village display occupying most of the space behind the couch (one of these Christmases I'm going to convince my mom to let me recreate the Battle of Hoth on the outskirts of the Village). As you can see, currently that area houses part of the folk art collection. If you squint real hard, you can see a portrait of my dad by Howard Finster on the right-hand side of the photo.

Here is the first of two pictures of cute animals--Jojo, the larger and more masculine of my parents' two cats:



Jojo is angling hard to win Everything Idol.

While I was home, Uncle Ken, one of my former English teachers, presented me with a new hat:



We're currently accepting applications for fall semester. Keg cups are three dollars, dudebro.

After a few days at home I drove down to Athens to see Chris, Amy and Ben. Amy graciously let me stay at her house for the trip. Here's me displaying my gratitude by drinking her bourbon:



And here's the second of the promised two cute animals--her dog, Moxie:



We all went out to Clocked, which wasn't around the last time I was in Athens, and I had a peanut-butter-and-bacon burger, which was surprisingly delicious. The tater tots are also highly recommended. Then it was off to the Manhattan, which was in Athens the last time I was there, and then after consulting the Flagpole (why Chris and Ben didn't have the ABC section memorized already, I don't know) we discovered that the Go Bar hosts "Indie Rock Karaoke" on Thursday nights. The description of this event reads: "If you're sick of 'Baby Got Back,' wear your Chucks and come on by. Every Thursday, 10 p.m." I was already wearing Chucks. I was mocked by my friends--friends whom I haven't seen in months, friends I count on to be there for me in good times and bad. Someday, I will make them pay.

I've mentioned my mild karaoke obsession before; in fact, reading through that earlier post, I discovered this little rumination: "I'm convinced that there's a fortune to be made in recording karaoke versions of relatively obscure alt-rock songs. I know it's fun to sing Bon Jovi, but if any karaoke place ever had a Pixies song in its selection, I would probably die of happiness." Well lo and fucking behold, someone has taken my suggestion, and that someone's name is DJ Geoff. The Go Bar's Indie Rock Karaoke songbook has a good half-page of Pixies songs sans vocals. And I didn't even die! I did, however, sing a frighteningly intense version of "Debaser." That was fun. (Somewhat inexplicably, the songbook also has a huge Dismemberment Plan selection. Also, it has explanations for why certain questionable songs, for example anything that might be heard on a Top 40 station, are included--i.e. "It came with the stand" or "Came with a White Stripes song.")

The next day I accompanied Amy to Vision Video to find some filmed entertainment to occupy her time after I left. At the store, we came acoss these two DVDs right next to each other. Let it never be said that Pierce Brosnan doesn't have range:



See, the slight smile on the Thomas Crown Affair cover indicates that he will most likely make out with Rene Russo during the course of the film. Sorry, Geoffrey Rush.

On the way back from Athens I stopped in tha ATL to see Chris 2 and talk about comics and Star Wars; the consensus is that all the little inconsistencies and "what the hell?" moments are the result of poor filmmaking, but can be easily rationalized if you're deluded enough. As we are.

Chris also slipped me an advance copy of Get Behind Me Satan, the new White Stripes album. The verdict? It's damn good. It's not a stone masterpiece like Elephant; on first listen, it even sounds more like a collection of unfinished demos and halfway-thought-out ideas than a real album. But if you let it score your daily life for a few days, its charms reveal itself. Jack White's guitar, always the most powerful weapon in his arsenal, is relegated to backup duty or even set aside entirely in favor of piano (on most tracks) or marimba (on a couple). There are no blistering "Ball and Biscuit"-style solos, and few of the thunderous blues riffs that characterized earlier Stripes albums. There is, of course, the bludgeoning robot-cock-rock of the lead track and first single "Blue Orchid," which sounds like every 70s arena-rock band compressed into two-and-a-half minutes and rocks as hard as anything in the band's catalog. The "Blue Orchid" riff is really a work of art, as it recalls an entire decade and genre of music while being almost completely divorced from what an electric guitar actually sounds like. It's an abstract concept almost, this huge vibrating wave that sets off the triggers in the back of our heads labeled "Foreigner." "Blue Orchid" renders the "garage rock" label completely obsolete; any garage this was recorded in probably also housed a Millennium Falcon.

Aside from the two other lurching axe workouts "Instinct Blues" and "Red Rain," Get Behind Me Satan maintains a more subdued, if not exactly mellow, tone. The marimba-based "The Nurse" creates a creepy, menacing atmosphere, punctuated by tuneless bursts of guitar noise, but by the end it never really goes anywhere; you expect it to break out into a full-fledged classic Stripes barnburner, but it just builds and then ends. More successful are "My Doorbell" and "The Denial Twist," both built on Jack's Jerry Lee Lewis piano pounding and Meg White's cymbal-happy stomping. "The Denial Twist" even has what sounds like an honest-to-god bassline. That's one of the more interesting things about the album: while, in general, it sounds less complete and polished than Elephant, these songs might be more difficult for Jack and Meg to replicate live. There was plenty of overdubbing on the previous album, but it was largely guitars on top of guitars; here it's two or three different instruments.

The fair-to-negative reviews of Get Behind Me Satan have largely focused on Jack's motives for making what the reviewers see as a sub-par album (i.e., is he deliberately sabotaging expectations a la Dylan's Self Portrait?), but that take assumes that Jack gives a shit what rock writers think about him. Reviewers have also used up a good bit of ink trying to discern which songs are about former paramour Renee Zellweger. Whereas on previous albums you just sort of assumed he was singing about Meg (or at least some nameless red-haired girl), here nearly every song is a breakup song (particularly the ballads "White Moon," "As Ugly as I Seem" and "Forever for Her (Is Over for Me"), and those that aren't seem to be about Rita Hayworth. Is Hayworth a stand-in for Zellweger? Is "Take, Take, Take," a jaunty little tale in which the narrator asks Hayworth for an autograph and becomes increasingly stalkerish as she refuses to take a picture with him or give him a lock of hair, really an extended metaphor for his relationship with Bridget Jones? It's possible, I guess. And, as usual, there's plenty of weirdness involving his relationship with Meg. On "Passive Manipulation," she sings "Women, listen to your mothers / Don't just succumb to the wishes of your brothers...You need to know the difference between a father and a lover," and on the album-closing "I'm Lonely (But I Ain't That Lonely Yet)," Jack enumerates the charms of his mother, his sister, a homely girl with her hair in a net, and drowning, but stops himself from succumbing by singing the title.

So Get Behind Me Satan is frustrating at times, and kind of a downer, but it's no less fascinating an addition to the White Stripes saga than any of their previous albums. But if you miss the exuberance of Elephant or White Blood Cells, take heart: Jack has apparently found and married his "red hair with a curl" girl, so maybe the next disc will be a big happy weird love triangle instead of a big weird sad love triangle.

BONUS! Brief reviews of books I read on the trip:

The Partly Cloudy Patriot by Sarah Vowell - She's got a quick wit and a real thing for democracy and civic responsibility, but for the most part these essays just make me wish I was reading David Sedaris--he has a way of drawing larger conclusions from similarly mundane topics that give his essays more staying power than these slight ruminations.

Like the Red Panda by Andrea Seigel - Picked this up on a whim thanks to the title (the red panda and its spectacular cuteness was a recent conversation topic) and a back-cover blurb from Chuck Klosterman ("If Helen Fielding had been born in 1979 and become a hyper-precocious Goth kid whose favorite book was Prozac Nation, she probably would have ended up writing exactly like Andrea Seigel") that could easily be a backhanded compliment or even an outright diss. Occasionally funny but mainly just clever, and the big ending seems kind of forced, deliberately denying the reader hope of reconciliation (though the breakdown in the fictional conceit at the end is interesting). The best parts are the observations of high-school types, and main character Stella's skittish foster parents are some nicely drawn characters. Mainly this made me think "Wow! She was born in 1979! That's really young to have written a novel! That's my age! Oh wait, my age is 25! My age is no longer that young! Boy!"

Kick Me: Adventures in Adolescence by Paul Feig - Feig created Freaks & Geeks, and many of the experiences he recalls in this book must have served as direct inspiration for F&G episodes. Feig isn't a great prose stylist, but his childhood was spectacularly embarrassing, and this book is frequently both hilarious and painful. You might like this more if you've seen F&G, but however bad your adolescence was, you'll just be glad you weren't named Paul Feig.
|