Let's dig through the four-for-a-dollar comics-commentary box and see what we can find:
New X-Men
Thanks to everybody for the kind words on last week's New X-Men post, and particular thanks to Fanboy Rampage, Insult to Injury, Sean T. Collins, Neilalien and anybody else who linked to the post. GLFC reader Christopher wrote in with an astute comment on the U-Men, the "fallen world" and the audience's role in the X-Men's lack of evolution--so astute, in fact, that I'm kicking myself for not thinking of it first. His point is that the U-Men, humans who profess to love mutants so much that they want to become mutants, which in turn leads them to kill mutants to harvest their organs, represent the readership--literally, they're "you-men." Just as the U-Men claim to be the next step in evolution but are actually part of Sublime's plan to keep the mutants from evolving, the majority of X-Men fans (and the publisher, for that matter) claim to be in favor of progress but summarily reject anything that takes their beloved characters out of the status quo they were in when the readers were twelve years old. See, for instance, how Marvel has decided to build on the new foundation laid by Grant Morrison's run, which as I stated earlier was an inoculation against all the old X-Men tropes made popular by Chris Claremont: by handing the keys to the X-Men franchise back to Claremont. You can see a preview of his upcoming return to Uncanny X-Men here; it's like New X-Men never happened. (The preview also points out one of the more immediate pleasures of Morrison's New X-Men, the one that makes you want to read the comics in order to find all the subtext: Morrison's characters have witty, interesting, intelligent things to say to each other. His dialogue isn't particuarly "realistic," but it conveys real emotion and real points of view. Claremont's dialogue conveys the feeling that the characters are little more than exposition machines and robots programmed to embody one and only one character trait. They feel as two-dimensional as the paper they're printed on. Perhaps this is a subtle continuation of Morrison's metafictional explorations, but I doubt it.)
To properly address Christopher's comment requires more thought than I'm able to muster up at the moment, but it has got me interested in the idea of "the fall" in New X-Men. That idea just sort of popped out at me when I was putting the initial essay together, so I didn't get into it too deeply, but I think it's worth exploring further. Emma Frost completes her seduction of Cyclops when she tells him to "stop being such an old super hero" and "fall;" the U-Men refuse to breath the air of the "fallen world;" Beak literally falls after standing up to Magneto, but survives and returns to fight Magneto at the head of a ragtag group of X-Men; U-Men leader John Sublime falls to his (apparent) death. In Morrison's second issue, Cyclops and Wolverine fall from the sky as Sentinels attack their jet. Their conversation as the jet crashes, which seemed like clever throwaway dialogue at the time, now seems central to Morrison's handling of Cyclops's fall from super hero to human being:
CYCLOPS: Relax. I've survived more jet aircraft crashes than any other mutant. Insurance takes care of everything.
WOLVERINE: You know what I admire most about you, Summers? Your icy calm lunacy under pressure.
CYCLOPS: Call me Cyclops during missions, Wolverine. It keeps things straight.
There's lots more to explore here, but I don't quite have a handle on it yet. In the meantime, check out this elegant little essay on New X-Men at John's Commonplace Book.
Be a Man
I picked up this little comic by Jeffrey Brown from Top Shelf (May-retta's finest comics publisher) at WizardWorld LA. Brown is an associate of Paul Hornschemeier and the cartoonist of the autobiographical graphic novels Clumsy and Unlikely, which I had avoided, despite excellent reviews, because they gave off a very "sensitive tortured artist talks about how sensitive and tortured he is" vibe. If I wanted to hear that, I'd listen to myself.
But whether that's a fair description of Clumsy and Unlikely or not, Brown is fully aware that that's exactly how he's going to be perceived by many readers and non-readers. Be a Man is his hilarious riposte to such ill-informed critics. It's a series of short vignettes, each one apparently an inversion of a similar scene from Clumsy, which recast Brown as a caricature of your basic modern neanderthal, the kind of guy the word "guy" was invented for. Or, as "Jeffrey Brown" himself puts it: "Rarrr, beer, sex, sports, ungh, unh, porn, kick ass, fuck, explosions, trucks, breasts, meat, bitch." Over the course of these 29 vignettes, most of them dealing with "Brown"'s attempts to get laid, Brown dismantles both the "guy" image and his own sensitive artiste persona, revealing them both for the pathetic facades they are. It's uncomfortable, funny stuff, and a great showcase for Brown's rubbery, deceptively sketchy cartooning; in a short gag with "Before" and "After" versions of a single panel from Clumsy, Brown displays his command of the craft by using a few extra lines and shadows to turn himself and his girlfriend into Hollywood sex gods.
Be a Man is ultimately too slight and too focused on a single point to join any sort of comics pantheon, but it's a great introduction to Brown's work. And it makes me want to read Clumsy, because it shows that Brown, unlike many indy autobiographical cartoonists, has a sense of humor about his own shortcomings and, more importantly, perspective on his own work. Another recent autobio graphic novel about a sensitive, tortured artist, Craig Thompson's highly-regarded Blankets, is begging for the sharp critical self-awareness that Brown displays in Be a Man.
You can buy Be a Man and Jeffrey Brown's other books here.
Hellboy
The movie Hellboy opens this weekend, and everybody I know has one of two reactions: "That looks retarded" or "That looks awesome." Me, I don't know. It's weird to see Hellboy as a big tentpole action-flick, when it got its start as an excuse for creator Mike Mignola to draw Jack Kirby monsters hitting each other. Hellboy's main charm is not its large cast of oddballs, its involved ongoing good-vs.-evil story, or its mishmash of Silver Age superheroics, Lovecraftian horror, obscure folklore and action-hero cool; its main charm is the way Mignola draws all those wonderful monsters. Mignola's style is so specific--and the design of Hellboy and his companions so suited to that style--that it may not translate well to CGI and prosthetic makeup. Though Mignola was heavily involved with production, the look of the movie as seen in the trailers is more X-Men than Mignola. There's just not enough black; the average Hellboy page is composed of great jagged swathes of black ink, with the occasional flash of blood red peeking around a corner. But at the very least the movie looks like fun, and I find it hard to resist anything with Selma Blair, so there you go.
In case the movie piques your interest in the comics, I suggest you go with the short-story collection The Chained Coffin and Others. Hellboy publisher Dark Horse has recently reprinted all five Hellboy collections with big numbers on the spines, so you know in what order to read them, but the first, Seed of Destruction, from which much of the movie's story is taken, is also the weakest. Mignola, who had prior to Hellboy made a living as a superhero artist for Marvel and DC, was not yet confident in his writing abilities, so he asked John Byrne (Chris Claremont's old X-Men partner) to write the dialogue. But Byrne's old-school superhero verbosity doesn't mesh well with Mignola's inky art and unconventional page layouts. Better, instead, to get a taste of the Hellboy world with The Chained Coffin, which includes both Mignola's awkward first attempts at scripting ("The Wolves of St. August") and later stories in which Mignola's twisted sense of humor and affection for folklore bring out the best in his art ("The Corpse"). "The Corpse" is also currently available as a solo 25-cent comic, and it's a bargain at twice the price, but you'll have to venture to a comic shop to get it; find one near you with The Master List.
Dark Horses's Hellboy Zone is your one-stop source for all things Hellboy.
The Hellboy library, in order:
Vol. 1: Seed of Destruction
Vol. 2: Wake the Devil
Vol. 3: The Chained Coffin and Others
Vol. 4: The Right Hand of Doom
Vol. 5: Conqueror Worm
If you want to check out Mignola's work, but prefer men dressed as flying rodents to trash-talking demons, you might like 1990's Gotham by Gaslight, written by Brian Augustyn, in which a Victorian-era Batman squares off against Jack the Ripper. It's much less stupid than it sounds.











